I didnât vote in any way on the comment, but itâs plausible you could have different strategic choices. You could try to shift a large donor to cause areas outside of existing preferences to more effective ones (as is the EA âtruismâ) or you could try to discover and endorse the most effective charities within existing preferences. The latter seems to be discussed by Ozzie Gooen in this thread.
Perhaps disagree votes were along the lines that they did not think lobbying for different cause areas would work with Bezos.
Good points. Still, I feel like the phrase âit might be useful for EAs to try to nudgeâ is so qualified as to be hard for readers to disagree with offhand. Itâs not like he said âit will definitely be useful for EAs to invest a lot of effort into trying to convince Bezos to grant to some drastically different causes.â
Unless someone spends a significant amount of time researching this question to be confident that trying to nudge Bezos to give in different cause areas is a bad idea, it seems hard to know if thatâs a bad idea, and thus hard to âdisagree-karmaâ a comment that merely suggests it might be useful.
I didnât vote in any way on the comment, but itâs plausible you could have different strategic choices. You could try to shift a large donor to cause areas outside of existing preferences to more effective ones (as is the EA âtruismâ) or you could try to discover and endorse the most effective charities within existing preferences. The latter seems to be discussed by Ozzie Gooen in this thread.
Perhaps disagree votes were along the lines that they did not think lobbying for different cause areas would work with Bezos.
Good points. Still, I feel like the phrase âit might be useful for EAs to try to nudgeâ is so qualified as to be hard for readers to disagree with offhand. Itâs not like he said âit will definitely be useful for EAs to invest a lot of effort into trying to convince Bezos to grant to some drastically different causes.â
Unless someone spends a significant amount of time researching this question to be confident that trying to nudge Bezos to give in different cause areas is a bad idea, it seems hard to know if thatâs a bad idea, and thus hard to âdisagree-karmaâ a comment that merely suggests it might be useful.