This only applies to flavors of the Asymmetry that treat happiness as intrinsically valuable, such that you would pay to add happiness to a âneutralâ life (without relieving any suffering by doing so). If the reason you donât consider it good to create new lives with more happiness than suffering is that you donât think happiness is intrinsically valuable, at least not at the price of increasing suffering, then you canât get Dutch booked this way. See this comment.
This only applies to flavors of the Asymmetry that treat happiness as intrinsically valuable, such that you would pay to add happiness to a âneutralâ life (without relieving any suffering by doing so). If the reason you donât consider it good to create new lives with more happiness than suffering is that you donât think happiness is intrinsically valuable, at least not at the price of increasing suffering, then you canât get Dutch booked this way. See this comment.