jackva comments on More global warming might be good to mitigate the food shocks caused by abrupt sunlight reduction scenarios

[jackva]

Thanks for doing this (upvoted!).

This moves me somewhat, though I would still really love to see a serious examination of nuclear winter to get better estimates, getting to 5% of 95% population loss conditional on nuclear war seems really high esp given it does not seem to condition on great power war alone.

[Vasco Grilo🔸]

This moves me somewhat, though I would still really love to see a serious examination of nuclear winter to get better estimates

Agreed!

getting to 5% of 95% population loss conditional on nuclear war seems really high esp given it does not seem to condition on great power war alone.

I have clarified above the 5 % is conditional on a nuclear war causing a population loss of at least 10 % (not just a nuclear war).

[jackva]

Thanks, this makes a lot of sense then!