Not addressing every point but I think in some respects I agree that crime is C but then how much benefit the criminal gets/values is a case-by-case question, and we can’t just assume that in the irl case at hand that the benefit is (in the analogy) $101 instead of $1000
There’s real deadweight loss from the mineshaft drop/spending money on prisons, but also potentially real value to be gained from the crime itself (canonical case = speeding bc wife is going in to labor)
Remember, property damage as activism isn’t like simple theft—the property damage can cost society amount $X and benefits of activism feature can separately benefit society or be valued by the perpetrator at any other number $Y
I see what you’re getting at here. But if we agree that the externalities of crime aren’t internalized, then I think we’re just back in the position of the original post. You think the act utilitarian calculus checks you, I’m both skeptical that it does and think that there are non-act-utilitarian reasons why we ought to avoid lawbreaking.
Not addressing every point but I think in some respects I agree that crime is C but then how much benefit the criminal gets/values is a case-by-case question, and we can’t just assume that in the irl case at hand that the benefit is (in the analogy) $101 instead of $1000
There’s real deadweight loss from the mineshaft drop/spending money on prisons, but also potentially real value to be gained from the crime itself (canonical case = speeding bc wife is going in to labor)
Remember, property damage as activism isn’t like simple theft—the property damage can cost society amount $X and benefits of activism feature can separately benefit society or be valued by the perpetrator at any other number $Y
I see what you’re getting at here. But if we agree that the externalities of crime aren’t internalized, then I think we’re just back in the position of the original post. You think the act utilitarian calculus checks you, I’m both skeptical that it does and think that there are non-act-utilitarian reasons why we ought to avoid lawbreaking.