Where are all the comments, indeed...”I advise you to withdraw this post, cut out half the narrative crap, add some evidence and a model, make a recommendation, then repost it.”I think this is basically fair, though from my perspective the narrative crap is doing important work.I have limited capacity these days so I’m writing this argument as a serial, posting it as I can find the time. In the meanwhile, this sequence from a few years ago (a) makes a similar argument following the form you suggest.
Where are all the comments, indeed...
”I advise you to withdraw this post, cut out half the narrative crap, add some evidence and a model, make a recommendation, then repost it.”
I think this is basically fair, though from my perspective the narrative crap is doing important work.
I have limited capacity these days so I’m writing this argument as a serial, posting it as I can find the time.
In the meanwhile, this sequence from a few years ago (a) makes a similar argument following the form you suggest.