Grayden 🔸 comments on Why did CEA buy Wytham Abbey?

[Grayden 🔸]

Thanks, Neel. This is a very helpful comment. I now don’t think our views are too far apart.

[Neel Nanda]

Thanks! Glad to hear it. This classic Yudkowsky post is a significant motivator. Key quote:

But if you are running on corrupted hardware, then the reflective observation that it seems like a righteous and altruistic act to seize power for yourself—this seeming may not be be much evidence for the proposition that seizing power is in fact the action that will most benefit the tribe.

By the power of naive realism, the corrupted hardware that you run on, and the corrupted seemings that it computes, will seem like the fabric of the very world itself—simply the way-things-are.

And so we have the bizarre-seeming rule: “For the good of the tribe, do not cheat to seize power even when it would provide a net benefit to the tribe.”