Hey jackmalde, interesting idea—though I think I’d lean against writing it. I guess the main reason is something like: There are quite a few issues to explore on the above list so if someone is searching around for something (rather than if they have something in mind already), they might be able to find an idea there. I guess despite what I said to Michael above, I do want people to see it as some positive signal if something’s on the list. Having a list of things not on the list would probably not add a lot, because the reasons would just be pretty weak things like “brief investigation + asking around didn’t make this seem compelling acc to our assumptions”. Insofar as soeone was already thinking of working on something and they saw that, they probably wouldn’t take it as much reason to change course. Does that make sense?
Hi Arden, yeah that makes sense. You’ve definitely given the EA community a lot to work on with this post so probably not worth overcomplicating things.
Hey jackmalde, interesting idea—though I think I’d lean against writing it. I guess the main reason is something like: There are quite a few issues to explore on the above list so if someone is searching around for something (rather than if they have something in mind already), they might be able to find an idea there. I guess despite what I said to Michael above, I do want people to see it as some positive signal if something’s on the list. Having a list of things not on the list would probably not add a lot, because the reasons would just be pretty weak things like “brief investigation + asking around didn’t make this seem compelling acc to our assumptions”. Insofar as soeone was already thinking of working on something and they saw that, they probably wouldn’t take it as much reason to change course. Does that make sense?
Hi Arden, yeah that makes sense. You’ve definitely given the EA community a lot to work on with this post so probably not worth overcomplicating things.