Yes, poorer people are not a monolith! Some people from our background (especially the people who chose to stick around EA long enough to be on the forum) will prefer current EA norms and feel grateful for them. I don’t mean to dismiss your experiences at all. There are many different socioeconomic cultures that are underrepresented in EA, so I don’t know what direction we should shift our norms in overall. Maybe there is that much diversity even within the US. I was speaking about my personal experience as someone from this background and the experiences of all the people I know well enough to know their perspectives from this background. I’m sorry I gave the impression I was trying to speak for you. I also wasn’t accusing us at all of having lack of control, just having the right to prefer different norms if we want to. Thanks so much for sharing your perspective! I do wish you had done so more politely though.
I’m curious: Do you feel like your wider lower class culture was very different from mine, or is it more that your family held different views that were a minority? Also, where were you raised and what role did religion play? My experience comes from Sacramento, California and religion was rarely discussed. I hope you don’t mind me asking these questions; There are so few of us around that EA needs all the data on us it can get!
Yes, poorer people are not a monolith! Some people from our background (especially the people who chose to stick around EA long enough to be on the forum) will prefer current EA norms and feel grateful for them. I don’t mean to dismiss your experiences at all. There are many different socioeconomic cultures that are underrepresented in EA, so I don’t know what direction we should shift our norms in overall. Maybe there is that much diversity even within the US. I was speaking about my personal experience as someone from this background and the experiences of all the people I know well enough to know their perspectives from this background. I’m sorry I gave the impression I was trying to speak for you. I also wasn’t accusing us at all of having lack of control, just having the right to prefer different norms if we want to. Thanks so much for sharing your perspective! I do wish you had done so more politely though.
I’m curious: Do you feel like your wider lower class culture was very different from mine, or is it more that your family held different views that were a minority? Also, where were you raised and what role did religion play? My experience comes from Sacramento, California and religion was rarely discussed. I hope you don’t mind me asking these questions; There are so few of us around that EA needs all the data on us it can get!
If anyone’s curious about GoodEAGoneBad’s reply, we continue the conversation in a comment I made sharing this shortform on this post: https://​​forum.effectivealtruism.org/​​posts/​​2JXLxKbSsbicnt9N9/​​ea-needs-life-veterans-and-less-smart-people