Edit: I misread and thought you were saying non-Malthusian worlds had more lives at first; realized you said the opposite, so we’re saying the same thing and we agree. Will have to do more math about this.
This is an interesting point that I hadn’t considered! I think you’re right that non-Malthusian futures are much larger than Malthusian futures in some cases...though if i.e. the “Malthusian” constraint is digital lives or such, not sure.
I think the argument you make actually cuts the other way. That to go back to the expected value...the case where the single death is deriving its EV from is precisely the non-Malthusian scenarios (when its progeny is not replaced by future progeny) so its EV actually remains the same. The extinction EV is the one that reduces...so you’ll actually get a number much less than 10^10 if you have high credence that Malthusianism is true and think Malthusian worlds have more people.
But, if you believe the opposite...that Malthusian worlds have more people, which I have not thought about but actually think might be true, yes a bigger gap than 10^10; will have to think about this.
Edit: I misread and thought you were saying non-Malthusian worlds had more lives at first; realized you said the opposite, so we’re saying the same thing and we agree. Will have to do more math about this.
This is an interesting point that I hadn’t considered! I think you’re right that non-Malthusian futures are much larger than Malthusian futures in some cases...though if i.e. the “Malthusian” constraint is digital lives or such, not sure.
I think the argument you make actually cuts the other way. That to go back to the expected value...the case where the single death is deriving its EV from is precisely the non-Malthusian scenarios (when its progeny is not replaced by future progeny) so its EV actually remains the same. The extinction EV is the one that reduces...so you’ll actually get a number much less than 10^10 if you have high credence that Malthusianism is true and think Malthusian worlds have more people.
But, if you believe the opposite...that Malthusian worlds have more people, which I have not thought about but actually think might be true, yes a bigger gap than 10^10; will have to think about this.
Thanks! Does this make sense to you?