Hi! I really appreciate you writing this, it offers a level of thoughtful introspection that is otherwise difficult to inspect by people like me (community builder).
Can you imagine a group that you would feel motivated to spend time in, that would be EA affiliated? Iâd love to know what aspects would be appealing and any constraints it would have to satisfy.
There seems to be a tension, where EA is exciting as a sort of intellectual project, where you read things and share thoughts and learn new stuff, but the energy to sustain that sort of involvement is difficult to maintain.
A social scene where everyone hangs out is easier to be a part of, but thenâwhats the point? Plus, lots of people already have a roster full of friends and families and donât need another social group.
I think if anyone is attracted to the intellectual project, but there arenât any formats that make it easy for them to engage, this might be solvable with thought event design. If the intellectual project is too taxing in an otherwise busy life (work, family, other interests etc), Iâm not sure thereâs a way to meaningfully re-engage the old-hand EAs.
This seems to rhyme with a concern Iâve had when planning programmes for EAGxAustralasiaâwhat talks and workshops make sense under the âglobal health and developmentâ banner?
A very naive categorisation of GHD content thatâs easy to put on at EAGx:
Updates from a particular organisation doing direct work.
Often very interesting; risks being too niche. Organisations end up being specialists in the logistics and research of their intervention.
Updates from research organisation (e.g. Institute for Poverty Action) about upcoming promising interventions
Rehash key GHD ideas for the part of the EAGx audience that hadnât heard it before
This relates to your point (5) aboveâhow much GHD stuff has been âsolvedâ?
Itâs quite difficult to figure out what content would be exciting to EAGx attendees, and actually pushes their thinking beyond âhere is information about another type of interventionâ.
From my position, it seems like other cause areas are grappling with bigger, more fundamental and less âsolvedâ questions that make it easier to find relevant content for an EAGx audience.
But, one thing Iâm taking from this postâthere are still GHD topics to grapple with (systems change vs direct delivery, cash benchmarking, other career paths, funding transparency /â scrutiny). Going to take inspo from this when planning our 2026 conference programme.