Thank you very much for the review and aggregation of all these forecasts! Very nice!
I just have one point to add:
As the first aggregate prediction, you mention the AI Impacts’ 2023 survey of machine learning researchers. Your post gives the impression that it produced an aggregate forecast of 50% by 2047 for human-level AI. I think this is at least imprecise, if not incorrect.
AI Impacts asked about the timing of human-level performance by asking some participants about how soon they expect “high-level machine intelligence” (HLMI) and asking others about how soon they expect “full automation of labor” (FAOL). The resulting aggregate forecast gave a 50% chance of HLMI by 2047 and a 50% chance of FAOL by 2116. In your post, you ignore that AI Impacts uses two different concepts for human-level AI and just report the aggregate forecast for HLMI under the headline of human-level AI.
I think this is unfortunate because this difference matters. One of your main points is that you claim that experts think human-level AI is likely to arrive in your lifetime. However, most of us will probably not be alive in 2116.
Thank you very much for the review and aggregation of all these forecasts! Very nice!
I just have one point to add:
As the first aggregate prediction, you mention the AI Impacts’ 2023 survey of machine learning researchers. Your post gives the impression that it produced an aggregate forecast of 50% by 2047 for human-level AI. I think this is at least imprecise, if not incorrect.
AI Impacts asked about the timing of human-level performance by asking some participants about how soon they expect “high-level machine intelligence” (HLMI) and asking others about how soon they expect “full automation of labor” (FAOL). The resulting aggregate forecast gave a 50% chance of HLMI by 2047 and a 50% chance of FAOL by 2116. In your post, you ignore that AI Impacts uses two different concepts for human-level AI and just report the aggregate forecast for HLMI under the headline of human-level AI.
I think this is unfortunate because this difference matters. One of your main points is that you claim that experts think human-level AI is likely to arrive in your lifetime. However, most of us will probably not be alive in 2116.