Oh yeah, no I agree with that. I have lost at least one EA friend partly because I wasn’t willing enough to condemn Hanania (despite saying that he said racist stuff and I didn’t want him to speak and pushing for discussion that lead to him being removed as a speaker). People pretty get annoyed at me for what I consider to be milquetoast takes or for trying to reach consensus on difficult discussion[1], I have received an angry screed for criticism of an EA leader. I don’t think EA is particularly safe for me[2]. My instincts here aren’t that this is good.
But I claim that there are lines that shouldn’t be crossed and if that empowers people I don’t like, in the short term, so be it. It’s what I think.
I think there is a line that Hanania can cross and (until he uncrosses it, with some cost) I will push for large costs to be imposed on him. For me, he has crossed that line and I am pretty confused how much value he should create before I say it’s more than the harm but I don’t think he’s done enough so far.
Though this is part of the issue, we’re all scared and so fragile. I imagine that some minority EAs feels this way. I talked and read things from some around the bostrom stuff that felt this way.
Oh yeah, no I agree with that. I have lost at least one EA friend partly because I wasn’t willing enough to condemn Hanania (despite saying that he said racist stuff and I didn’t want him to speak and pushing for discussion that lead to him being removed as a speaker). People pretty get annoyed at me for what I consider to be milquetoast takes or for trying to reach consensus on difficult discussion[1], I have received an angry screed for criticism of an EA leader. I don’t think EA is particularly safe for me[2]. My instincts here aren’t that this is good.
But I claim that there are lines that shouldn’t be crossed and if that empowers people I don’t like, in the short term, so be it. It’s what I think.
I think there is a line that Hanania can cross and (until he uncrosses it, with some cost) I will push for large costs to be imposed on him. For me, he has crossed that line and I am pretty confused how much value he should create before I say it’s more than the harm but I don’t think he’s done enough so far.
I imagine they would characterise it differently.
Though this is part of the issue, we’re all scared and so fragile. I imagine that some minority EAs feels this way. I talked and read things from some around the bostrom stuff that felt this way.