The lack of examples is totally reasonable at this early stage
It mostly seemed clear to me what this organisation’s scope, aims, and differences from 80k would be
The important uncertainties I’d have about the organisation’s intended scope, aims, and differences from 80k were mostly already in their explicit Open Questions.
There were some other uncertainties I had, which I raised in other comments. But that process itself seems like an example of why it’s ok for the materials to have been fairly abstract at this stage; it’s probably more efficient for the authors to (a) produce what they produced, post it publicly, have people ask about the specific confusing bits, and then provide clarity by answering those questions publicly, rather than (b) trying to guess by themselves what will and won’t be clear to other people.
Then they can adjust their materials in light of public feedback and questions.
(It’s often hard to guess what will be clear to other people when you yourself have lots of context on what you were thinking and why.)
FWIW, I personally felt like:
The lack of examples is totally reasonable at this early stage
It mostly seemed clear to me what this organisation’s scope, aims, and differences from 80k would be
The important uncertainties I’d have about the organisation’s intended scope, aims, and differences from 80k were mostly already in their explicit Open Questions.
There were some other uncertainties I had, which I raised in other comments. But that process itself seems like an example of why it’s ok for the materials to have been fairly abstract at this stage; it’s probably more efficient for the authors to (a) produce what they produced, post it publicly, have people ask about the specific confusing bits, and then provide clarity by answering those questions publicly, rather than (b) trying to guess by themselves what will and won’t be clear to other people.
Then they can adjust their materials in light of public feedback and questions.
(It’s often hard to guess what will be clear to other people when you yourself have lots of context on what you were thinking and why.)