I think if you’re colouring the situation in a way that would influence the person’s perception when they go to comment or vote, that would be against the rules of the EA forum.
Separately, I think I probably am against asking people to pile on to a post, even if you’re not directly telling them which way to pile on? I think it’s bad to have comments sections be emotionally charged regardless of which direction the sentiment points on net. We want to incentivise deliberation and good judgement, not moral crusading.
I think if you’re colouring the situation in a way that would influence the person’s perception when they go to comment or vote, that would be against the rules of the EA forum.
Separately, I think I probably am against asking people to pile on to a post, even if you’re not directly telling them which way to pile on? I think it’s bad to have comments sections be emotionally charged regardless of which direction the sentiment points on net. We want to incentivise deliberation and good judgement, not moral crusading.