This is something we should think about more as a mod team- I’ll discuss it with them.
Our current politics policy is still this. But it arguably wasn’t designed with our current situation in mind. In my view, it’d be a bad thing if discussions on the Forum became too tied to the news cycle (It generally seems true that once something is on the news, you are at least several years too late to change it), our impact has historically not been had by working in the most politically salient areas (neglectedness isn’t a perfect proxy but it still matters). However, it’d also be wrong if the Forum couldn’t discuss politically salient issues while they are going on, and there is something readers could do to stop them.
FWIW in this particular situation (and I haven’t conferred with the mod team) I don’t see this thread as being against Forum rules, because the participants could reasonably believe (or for that matter, not believe) that preventing authoritarian takeover in the US is a relevant cause area to EA.
This is something we should think about more as a mod team- I’ll discuss it with them.
Our current politics policy is still this. But it arguably wasn’t designed with our current situation in mind. In my view, it’d be a bad thing if discussions on the Forum became too tied to the news cycle (It generally seems true that once something is on the news, you are at least several years too late to change it), our impact has historically not been had by working in the most politically salient areas (neglectedness isn’t a perfect proxy but it still matters). However, it’d also be wrong if the Forum couldn’t discuss politically salient issues while they are going on, and there is something readers could do to stop them.
FWIW in this particular situation (and I haven’t conferred with the mod team) I don’t see this thread as being against Forum rules, because the participants could reasonably believe (or for that matter, not believe) that preventing authoritarian takeover in the US is a relevant cause area to EA.