I think that peer review is so poor that probably just the forum alone produces work that is less in need of replication. I guess that’s not really about the system.
And yes, we should build a better system, but still. Peer review vs upvotes on journal sites, I would pick the latter.
And yet argue it you shall.
I think that peer review is so poor that probably just the forum alone produces work that is less in need of replication. I guess that’s not really about the system.
And yes, we should build a better system, but still. Peer review vs upvotes on journal sites, I would pick the latter.
Maybe we could discuss it in the comments of https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/topics/peer-review