I’d definitely like to see this included in future models (I’m surprised Hanson didn’t write about this in his Loud aliens paper). My intuition is that this changes little for the conclusions of SIA or anthropic decision theory with total utilitarianism, and that this weakens the case for many aliens for SSA, since our atypicality (or earliness) is decreased if we expect habitable planets around longer lived stars to have smaller volumes and/or lower metabolisms.
That’s my read too.
Also agreed that with the basic modeling element of catastrophes (w/ various anthropic accounts, etc) is more important/robust than the combo with other anthropic assumptions,.
That’s my read too.
Also agreed that with the basic modeling element of catastrophes (w/ various anthropic accounts, etc) is more important/robust than the combo with other anthropic assumptions,.