For example, a preference utilitarian can think there is an objective moral fact that it is bad to, all else equal, do something to someone that they disprefer, even though the “badness” comes from their dispreference. It seems like that would be subjective only if the claim was that it was bad according to some observer.
I’m personally not sympathetic to such a claim. What makes it objective? Rather, to me, it’s just bad to the person who disprefers it (and possibly other individuals). They are an observer. They are observers of their own mental states and things in the world, and they have attitudes about them.
The view I describe in this piece could be made objective in the way you describe, though.
I’m personally not sympathetic to such a claim. What makes it objective? Rather, to me, it’s just bad to the person who disprefers it (and possibly other individuals). They are an observer. They are observers of their own mental states and things in the world, and they have attitudes about them.
The view I describe in this piece could be made objective in the way you describe, though.