0.864 s (= 24*60^2/(100*10^3)) of excruciating pain in humans neutralises 1 day of fully healthy life in humans. Do you think this is “unconventional and extremely skewed
Yes. I can’t think of any pain in which I would prefer to die than suffer for 0.864 seconds per day, particularly not if the remaining aspects of my life were “practically maximally happy”.[1]
I find it even harder to imagine that an insect can distinguish between painful sensations to the degree that a pain scale with at least 100k points on it would be appropriate to approximate their welfare on,[2] still less that an appropriate use of such a scale is to multiply a human/insect welfare ratio to conclude that the complete cessation of function of that simple insect nervous system is a few orders of magnitude more intense conscious experience than the “practically maximally happy” (or even average) utility of a human.
I mean, they’ve only got 200k neurons to divide between all their functions. (This isn’t an argument for neuron count being a good proxy for moral weights overall, merely an observation of how extreme the pain scale looks in the context of how simple the insect’s system for parsing stimuli appears to be)
Yes. I can’t think of any pain in which I would prefer to die than suffer for 0.864 seconds per day, particularly not if the remaining aspects of my life were “practically maximally happy”.[1]
I find it even harder to imagine that an insect can distinguish between painful sensations to the degree that a pain scale with at least 100k points on it would be appropriate to approximate their welfare on,[2] still less that an appropriate use of such a scale is to multiply a human/insect welfare ratio to conclude that the complete cessation of function of that simple insect nervous system is a few orders of magnitude more intense conscious experience than the “practically maximally happy” (or even average) utility of a human.
If I did think [potential] sub second pain was as significant as an entire day’s welfare, I would probably not endorse electrical stunning...
I mean, they’ve only got 200k neurons to divide between all their functions. (This isn’t an argument for neuron count being a good proxy for moral weights overall, merely an observation of how extreme the pain scale looks in the context of how simple the insect’s system for parsing stimuli appears to be)