In my opinion, a strong downvote is too harsh for a plausibly good faith comment with some potentially valuable criticism, even if (initially) vague.
They elaborated on some of their concerns in the replies.
You could ask them to elaborate more if they can (without deanonymizing people without their consent) on specific issues instead of strong downvoting.
Current theme: default
Less Wrong (text)
Less Wrong (link)
In my opinion, a strong downvote is too harsh for a plausibly good faith comment with some potentially valuable criticism, even if (initially) vague.
They elaborated on some of their concerns in the replies.
You could ask them to elaborate more if they can (without deanonymizing people without their consent) on specific issues instead of strong downvoting.