Not as pithy, but just a flag that I think the question implicitly raised by Tom’s comment and the answer in David’s are pretty important. This is a community which is willing to update actions based on theoretical arguments about what’s important. Of course I don’t expect an article to totally change people’s beliefs—let alone behaviours—but if it has a fraction of that effect I’d count it as cheap.
Not as pithy, but just a flag that I think the question implicitly raised by Tom’s comment and the answer in David’s are pretty important. This is a community which is willing to update actions based on theoretical arguments about what’s important. Of course I don’t expect an article to totally change people’s beliefs—let alone behaviours—but if it has a fraction of that effect I’d count it as cheap.