Interesting review as always Peter. I’ve looked at Toggl’s tour (and like its name for reasons you can claim a prize for guessing next time we chat ;), but could you say a bit more about what made you pick it over alternatives? I ask as someone who’s done time tracking for a while, and settled on http://www.paymo.biz/ but isn’t totally satisfied by it (mainly because of the time-consumingness of tagging my time in a fine-grained way).
Paul Christiano and Katja Grace jointly explored several different time-tracking apps and concluded that, while Toggl has flaws, it has fewer flaws than the alternatives. Independently, I did some research myself a while ago and also came to the conclusion that Toggl was superior to its rivals, though I can no longer recall the considerations that led me to reach this conclusion.
I prefer Toggl because it is fastest: a single keypress to stop the current timer or return to the last one, and a single key press followed by typing a uniquely-identifying substring to start a new timer. Katja and/or me also tried yast, freckle, clok, harvest, lumina, and a few other options I’ve forgotten about. All of these have more clicks/keystrokes per operation.
Toggl also works offline, which ruled out several alternatives, and has a reasonable (though not excellent) interface for viewing reports, and 3 levels of reporting (name of entry, job, and client).
Note that Toggl crashes constantly (perhaps 2-4 times a day for me on OSX), but it can be restarted in a few seconds each time, and so this isn’t a huge consideration for me.
Note that Toggl crashes constantly (perhaps 2-4 times a day for me on OSX), but it can be restarted in a few seconds each time, and so this isn’t a huge consideration for me.
Huh. Is that the desktop app? I’ve never used that app, but have had 0 problems with Toggl in any of it’s other manifestations (website, mobile, command line tools).
Interesting review as always Peter. I’ve looked at Toggl’s tour (and like its name for reasons you can claim a prize for guessing next time we chat ;), but could you say a bit more about what made you pick it over alternatives? I ask as someone who’s done time tracking for a while, and settled on http://www.paymo.biz/ but isn’t totally satisfied by it (mainly because of the time-consumingness of tagging my time in a fine-grained way).
Paul Christiano and Katja Grace jointly explored several different time-tracking apps and concluded that, while Toggl has flaws, it has fewer flaws than the alternatives. Independently, I did some research myself a while ago and also came to the conclusion that Toggl was superior to its rivals, though I can no longer recall the considerations that led me to reach this conclusion.
It would be cool if Paul and Katja published their results.
Also, I remembered the reason why I use Toggl is because you recommended it to me.
Though, like with Paul and Katja’s recommendation of Workflowy, I was skeptical at first.
I prefer Toggl because it is fastest: a single keypress to stop the current timer or return to the last one, and a single key press followed by typing a uniquely-identifying substring to start a new timer. Katja and/or me also tried yast, freckle, clok, harvest, lumina, and a few other options I’ve forgotten about. All of these have more clicks/keystrokes per operation.
Toggl also works offline, which ruled out several alternatives, and has a reasonable (though not excellent) interface for viewing reports, and 3 levels of reporting (name of entry, job, and client).
Note that Toggl crashes constantly (perhaps 2-4 times a day for me on OSX), but it can be restarted in a few seconds each time, and so this isn’t a huge consideration for me.
Huh. Is that the desktop app? I’ve never used that app, but have had 0 problems with Toggl in any of it’s other manifestations (website, mobile, command line tools).
I didn’t look at alternatives, so I can’t say why I picked it over alternatives. Toggl has a nice interface. Paymo looks fine, though!