I think that it seems like accusations of EA associations with white supremacy of various sorts come up enough to be pretty concerning.
I also think the claims would be equally concerning if JoshYou had said “white supremacists” or “really racist people” instead of “white nationalists” in the original post, so I feel uncertain that Buck stepping back the original post actually lessens the degree we ought to be concerned?
I also have other issues with the rest of the comment (namely being constantly worried about communists or nazis hiding everywhere, and generally bringing up nazi comparisons in these discussions, tends to reliably derail things and make it harder to discuss these things well, since there are few conversational moves as mindkilling as accusing the other side to be nazis or communists. It’s not that there are never nazis or communists, but if you want to have a good conversation, it’s better to avoid nazi or communist comparisons until you really have no other choice, or you can really really commit to handling the topic in an open-minded way.)
I didn’t really see the Nazi comparisons (I guess saying white nationalist is sort of one, but I personally associate white nationalism as a phrase much more with individuals in the US than Nazis, though that may be biased by being American).
I guess broadly a trend I feel like I’ve seen lately is occasionally people writing about witnessing racism in the EA community, and having what seem like really genuine concerns, and then those basically not being discussed (at least on the EA Forum) or being framed as shutting down conversation.
Thanks for elaborating!
I think that it seems like accusations of EA associations with white supremacy of various sorts come up enough to be pretty concerning.
I also think the claims would be equally concerning if JoshYou had said “white supremacists” or “really racist people” instead of “white nationalists” in the original post, so I feel uncertain that Buck stepping back the original post actually lessens the degree we ought to be concerned?
I didn’t really see the Nazi comparisons (I guess saying white nationalist is sort of one, but I personally associate white nationalism as a phrase much more with individuals in the US than Nazis, though that may be biased by being American).
I guess broadly a trend I feel like I’ve seen lately is occasionally people writing about witnessing racism in the EA community, and having what seem like really genuine concerns, and then those basically not being discussed (at least on the EA Forum) or being framed as shutting down conversation.