I think it’s important that Eliezer used the words “and not mention the obvious notion that” (emphasis added).
The use of the word “obvious” suggests that Eliezer thinks that Ted is either lying by not mentioning an obvious point, or he’s so stupid that he shouldn’t be contributing to the forum.
If Eliezer had simply dropped the word “obvious”, then I would agree with Aaron’s assessment.
However as is, I agree with JP’s assessment.
(Not that I’m a moderator, nor am I suggesting that my opinion should receive some special weight, just adding another perspective.)
My opinion placed zero weight on the argument that Eliezer is a high profile user of the forum, and harsh words from him may cut deeper, therefore he (arguably) has a stronger onus to be kind.
I think it’s important that Eliezer used the words “and not mention the obvious notion that” (emphasis added).
The use of the word “obvious” suggests that Eliezer thinks that Ted is either lying by not mentioning an obvious point, or he’s so stupid that he shouldn’t be contributing to the forum.
If Eliezer had simply dropped the word “obvious”, then I would agree with Aaron’s assessment.
However as is, I agree with JP’s assessment.
(Not that I’m a moderator, nor am I suggesting that my opinion should receive some special weight, just adding another perspective.)
My opinion placed zero weight on the argument that Eliezer is a high profile user of the forum, and harsh words from him may cut deeper, therefore he (arguably) has a stronger onus to be kind.