My overall sense of this is that I can imagine this process working out, but the first round of this should ideally just be run by you and some friends of yours, and should not require 100+ hours of volunteer time. My expectation is that after you spend 10 hours trying to actually follow this process, with just one or two projects, on your own or with some friends, that you will find that large parts of it won’t work as you expected and that the process you designed is a lot too rigid to produce useful evaluations.
My overall sense of this is that I can imagine this process working out, but the first round of this should ideally just be run by you and some friends of yours, and should not require 100+ hours of volunteer time. My expectation is that after you spend 10 hours trying to actually follow this process, with just one or two projects, on your own or with some friends, that you will find that large parts of it won’t work as you expected and that the process you designed is a lot too rigid to produce useful evaluations.