Sure, first 80k thought your counterfactual impact is “often negligible” due to replaceability, then they changed position toward replaceability being “very uncertain” in general. I don’t think you can just remove it from the model completely.
I also don’t think in the particular case of central EA organizations hiring the uncertainty is as big as in general / I’m uncertain about this, but my vague impression was there is a usually a selection of good candidates to choose from when they are hiring.
Here is 80k’s mea culpa on replaceability.
Sure, first 80k thought your counterfactual impact is “often negligible” due to replaceability, then they changed position toward replaceability being “very uncertain” in general. I don’t think you can just remove it from the model completely.
I also don’t think in the particular case of central EA organizations hiring the uncertainty is as big as in general / I’m uncertain about this, but my vague impression was there is a usually a selection of good candidates to choose from when they are hiring.