Ah sure, but I’m saying that no one gives this sort of money just because they’ve been asked to—it’s too large and long-lasting a commitment, and being asked is not a powerful enough reason or prompt. Asking them to sign the GWWC pledge may prompt them to make this public declaration, but only if they were already happy to give that sort of money.
In my experience, some of the people I’ve asked to take the pledge would have donated 10% “eventually”, but the pledge actually made them follow through for at least that year in particular where I’m confident they otherwise would not.
Some would have done so anyway, but I think the example set by hundreds of others, including some they know personally, normalises giving a large amount and makes them more likely to copy. Also making a public declaration makes people more likely to follow through.
We also obviously make arguments in favour of doing so. It rarely convinces people immediately but it contributes to moving them in that direction.
“but no one commits to donating 10% of their income every year until they retire because someone asked them to”
We do in our outreach efforts!
Ah sure, but I’m saying that no one gives this sort of money just because they’ve been asked to—it’s too large and long-lasting a commitment, and being asked is not a powerful enough reason or prompt. Asking them to sign the GWWC pledge may prompt them to make this public declaration, but only if they were already happy to give that sort of money.
In my experience, some of the people I’ve asked to take the pledge would have donated 10% “eventually”, but the pledge actually made them follow through for at least that year in particular where I’m confident they otherwise would not.
Some would have done so anyway, but I think the example set by hundreds of others, including some they know personally, normalises giving a large amount and makes them more likely to copy. Also making a public declaration makes people more likely to follow through.
We also obviously make arguments in favour of doing so. It rarely convinces people immediately but it contributes to moving them in that direction.