You are taking charitable interpretations to an absolute limit here. You seem to be saying “maybe Jacy was endorsing a highly expansive conception of ‘founding’ which implies that EA has hundreds of founders’”. This is indeed a logical possibility. But I think the correct credence to have in this possibility is ~0. Instead, we should have ~1 credence in the following “he said it knowing it is not true in order to further his career”. And by ‘founding’ he meant, “I’m in the same bracket as Will MacAskill”. Otherwise, why put it on your website and in your bio?
I don’t think it’s like “Jacy had an interpretation in mind and then chose statements”. I think it’s more like “Jacy wanted to say things that made himself look impressive, then with motivated reasoning talked himself into thinking it was reasonable to call himself a founder of EA, because that sounded cool”.
(Within this there’s a spectrum of more and less blameworthy versions, as well as the possibility of the straight-out lying version. My best guess is towards the blameworthy end of the not-lying versions, but I don’t really know.)
You are taking charitable interpretations to an absolute limit here. You seem to be saying “maybe Jacy was endorsing a highly expansive conception of ‘founding’ which implies that EA has hundreds of founders’”. This is indeed a logical possibility. But I think the correct credence to have in this possibility is ~0. Instead, we should have ~1 credence in the following “he said it knowing it is not true in order to further his career”. And by ‘founding’ he meant, “I’m in the same bracket as Will MacAskill”. Otherwise, why put it on your website and in your bio?
I don’t think it’s like “Jacy had an interpretation in mind and then chose statements”. I think it’s more like “Jacy wanted to say things that made himself look impressive, then with motivated reasoning talked himself into thinking it was reasonable to call himself a founder of EA, because that sounded cool”.
(Within this there’s a spectrum of more and less blameworthy versions, as well as the possibility of the straight-out lying version. My best guess is towards the blameworthy end of the not-lying versions, but I don’t really know.)