What would be worthy of an up vs down? I was thinking something along this line also though, but my thought was rank them based on didactic potential according to an SNT framework—If you think it is a really important concept(S) but not many people know about it(N), and people would be interested if they did find out (T), this is the highest priority page.
Is this what you meant by best books or were you just thinking rank them by how much you liked them?
I think anything would better than nothing. But yes ideally you could have a number of things to vote on—enjoyableness and usefulness. Or get people to estimate how much they’d have paid to read the book or something. But I think just straight up or down is a good place to begin.
Allow every page to have a karma rank and then advanced search and ranking
Want to find the best EA books? Rank them by Karma
Want to find the EA orgs in animal advocacy? Search them by that filter. Etc etc.
What would be worthy of an up vs down? I was thinking something along this line also though, but my thought was rank them based on didactic potential according to an SNT framework—If you think it is a really important concept(S) but not many people know about it(N), and people would be interested if they did find out (T), this is the highest priority page.
Is this what you meant by best books or were you just thinking rank them by how much you liked them?
I think anything would better than nothing. But yes ideally you could have a number of things to vote on—enjoyableness and usefulness. Or get people to estimate how much they’d have paid to read the book or something. But I think just straight up or down is a good place to begin.