I don’t know if it makes a lot of sense because yes, in theory from my viewpoint all “torture worlds” (N agents, all suffering the same amount of torture) are equivalent. I feel like that intuition is more right than just “more people = more torture”. I would call them equally bad worlds, and if the torture is preternatural and inescapable I have no way of choosing between them. But I also feel like this is twisting ourselves into examples that are completely unrealistic, to the point of almost uselessness; it is no wonder that our theories of ethics break down, same as most physics does at a black hole singularity.
I don’t know if it makes a lot of sense because yes, in theory from my viewpoint all “torture worlds” (N agents, all suffering the same amount of torture) are equivalent. I feel like that intuition is more right than just “more people = more torture”. I would call them equally bad worlds, and if the torture is preternatural and inescapable I have no way of choosing between them. But I also feel like this is twisting ourselves into examples that are completely unrealistic, to the point of almost uselessness; it is no wonder that our theories of ethics break down, same as most physics does at a black hole singularity.