Yep completely with Jason here. I voted a smidge in favor of giving the 100 million to animal rights orgs yet I’m pretty sure you’d consider me to have very human-friendly moral theories
To push that thinking a bit further compared with the general public, EAs have extremely animal friendly theories. For example I would easily be in the top 1 percent of animal-friendly-moral theory humans (maybe top 0.1 percent) but maybe in the bottom third of EAs?
That is a datapoint as much as many might mostly discount it.
What is your preferred moral theory out of interest?
When you say top 1 percent of animal-friendly-moral theory humans but maybe in the bottom third of EAs, is this just say hedonism but with moral weights that are far less animal-friendly than say RP’s?
Thanks Jack, I don’t have a clear answer to that right now. I have a messy mix of moral theories in which hedonism would contribute.
I’m so uncertain about the moral weights of animals right now (and more so after debate week, but updated a bit in favor of animals) and I value certainty quite a lot. I have quite a low threshold for feeling like Pascal is mugging me ;).
Yep completely with Jason here. I voted a smidge in favor of giving the 100 million to animal rights orgs yet I’m pretty sure you’d consider me to have very human-friendly moral theories
To push that thinking a bit further compared with the general public, EAs have extremely animal friendly theories. For example I would easily be in the top 1 percent of animal-friendly-moral theory humans (maybe top 0.1 percent) but maybe in the bottom third of EAs?
That is a datapoint as much as many might mostly discount it.
What is your preferred moral theory out of interest?
When you say top 1 percent of animal-friendly-moral theory humans but maybe in the bottom third of EAs, is this just say hedonism but with moral weights that are far less animal-friendly than say RP’s?
Thanks Jack, I don’t have a clear answer to that right now. I have a messy mix of moral theories in which hedonism would contribute.
I’m so uncertain about the moral weights of animals right now (and more so after debate week, but updated a bit in favor of animals) and I value certainty quite a lot. I have quite a low threshold for feeling like Pascal is mugging me ;).