I of course knew that FTX and Alameda were very closely related, that Sam and Caroline were dating and that the two organizations had very porous boundaries. But I did not know that the rest of the world did not know this, and I had no idea that it mattered much legally. They were both located in the Bahamas, and I definitely did not know enough finance law to know that these two organizations were supposed to operate at arms length.
Maybe there was someone else who did successfully put the pieces together and then stayed quiet, but I would definitely not treat this as a “smoking gun” since I saw it myself, as did many people I know, and neither me nor other people realized that this was actually pretty shady.
And legally there were actually distinct companies, at least the same way GiveWell and OpenPhil were different companies back in 2018 when they still worked in the same office and shared some leadership, and that itself doesn’t raise any flags for me. FTX and Alameda definitely actually were different companies with some offices being just for Alameda (like the one in Berkeley), though they definitely did not operate “at arms length” as I think the legal situation required.
I of course knew that FTX and Alameda were very closely related, that Sam and Caroline were dating and that the two organizations had very porous boundaries. But I did not know that the rest of the world did not know this, and I had no idea that it mattered much legally. They were both located in the Bahamas, and I definitely did not know enough finance law to know that these two organizations were supposed to operate at arms length.
Maybe there was someone else who did successfully put the pieces together and then stayed quiet, but I would definitely not treat this as a “smoking gun” since I saw it myself, as did many people I know, and neither me nor other people realized that this was actually pretty shady.
And legally there were actually distinct companies, at least the same way GiveWell and OpenPhil were different companies back in 2018 when they still worked in the same office and shared some leadership, and that itself doesn’t raise any flags for me. FTX and Alameda definitely actually were different companies with some offices being just for Alameda (like the one in Berkeley), though they definitely did not operate “at arms length” as I think the legal situation required.