I really like the framing in Does EA bring out the best in me? (and symmetrically, “When I’m interacting with the effective altruism community, do I help bring out the best in others?”)
But as written in this article, it doesn’t seem to mean anything more than “I don’t like EA”. For anything to always bring out its best, it would need to be unrealistically consistent (as you mention in the footnote)
I really like the framing in Does EA bring out the best in me? (and symmetrically, “When I’m interacting with the effective altruism community, do I help bring out the best in others?”)
But as written in this article, it doesn’t seem to mean anything more than “I don’t like EA”. For anything to always bring out its best, it would need to be unrealistically consistent (as you mention in the footnote)