Not that I know of, Nick Beckstead wrote a moderately negative review of civilizational refuges 7 years ago (note that this was back when longtermist EA had a lot less $s than we currently do).
One reason I’d like to write out a moderately detailed MVP is that then we can have a clear picture for others to critique concrete details of, suggest clear empirical or conceptual lines for further work, etc, rather than have most of this conversation a) be overly high-level or b) too tied in with/anchored to existing (non-longtermist) versions of what’s currently going on in adjacent spaces.
Not that I know of, Nick Beckstead wrote a moderately negative review of civilizational refuges 7 years ago (note that this was back when longtermist EA had a lot less $s than we currently do).
One reason I’d like to write out a moderately detailed MVP is that then we can have a clear picture for others to critique concrete details of, suggest clear empirical or conceptual lines for further work, etc, rather than have most of this conversation a) be overly high-level or b) too tied in with/anchored to existing (non-longtermist) versions of what’s currently going on in adjacent spaces.