Oh no, I wasn’t trying to imply that that’s what you were doing. I wanted to comment on it because I was extremely doubtful that any kind of intervention could have very high impact (not even as high as SM claims, even something around 70-75% would have been surprising to me) when I first came across it and considered it very implausible until seeing the evidence base for GIPT, which made me think it’s not quite so outlandish as to be totally implausible (although, as I said, I still have my doubts and don’t think SM makes a strong enough case for their figures). Just wanted to share this for anyone else who was in my position.
Oh no, I wasn’t trying to imply that that’s what you were doing. I wanted to comment on it because I was extremely doubtful that any kind of intervention could have very high impact (not even as high as SM claims, even something around 70-75% would have been surprising to me) when I first came across it and considered it very implausible until seeing the evidence base for GIPT, which made me think it’s not quite so outlandish as to be totally implausible (although, as I said, I still have my doubts and don’t think SM makes a strong enough case for their figures). Just wanted to share this for anyone else who was in my position.