I really don’t think the libertarian “if you don’t like it, go somewhere else” works here as the EA forum is pretty much the place where EA discussions are held. Sure, they happen on twitter and reddit too but you have to admit it’s not the same. Most discussions start here and are then picked up there.
I agree with your other arguments, I don’t want the culture of the site to drift too quickly because of a large influx of new folks. But why wouldn’t a cut off be sufficient for that? I don’t see why the power has to keep on increasing after, say, a 200 karma. Because at that point value lock-in might become an issue. Reminds me a bit of the average age of US senators being 64 years old. Not too dismiss the wisdom of experienced people, but insights from new folks is important too.
I really don’t think the libertarian “if you don’t like it, go somewhere else” works here as the EA forum is pretty much the place where EA discussions are held. Sure, they happen on twitter and reddit too but you have to admit it’s not the same. Most discussions start here and are then picked up there.
I agree with your other arguments, I don’t want the culture of the site to drift too quickly because of a large influx of new folks. But why wouldn’t a cut off be sufficient for that? I don’t see why the power has to keep on increasing after, say, a 200 karma. Because at that point value lock-in might become an issue. Reminds me a bit of the average age of US senators being 64 years old. Not too dismiss the wisdom of experienced people, but insights from new folks is important too.