Thanks for this too. I appreciate you’ve since moved on to other things, so this isn’t really your topic to engage on anymore. However, I’ll make two comments.
First, you said you read various things in the area, including by me, since 2015. It would have been really helpful (to me) if, given you had different views, you had engaged at the time and set out where you disagreed and what sort of evidence would have changed your mind.
Second, and similarly, I would really appreciate it if the current team at Open Philanthropy could more precisely set out their perspective on all this. I did have a few interactions with various Open Phil staff in 2021, but I wouldn’t say I’ve got anything like canonical answers on what their reservations are about 1. measuring outcomes in terms of SWB - Alex Berger’s recent technical update didn’t comment on this—and 2. doing more research or grantmaking into the things that, from the SWB perspective, seem overlooked.
This is an interesting conversation. It’s veering off into a separate topic. I wish there was a way to “rebase” these spin-off discussions into a different place. For better organisation.
Hello Luke,
Thanks for this too. I appreciate you’ve since moved on to other things, so this isn’t really your topic to engage on anymore. However, I’ll make two comments.
First, you said you read various things in the area, including by me, since 2015. It would have been really helpful (to me) if, given you had different views, you had engaged at the time and set out where you disagreed and what sort of evidence would have changed your mind.
Second, and similarly, I would really appreciate it if the current team at Open Philanthropy could more precisely set out their perspective on all this. I did have a few interactions with various Open Phil staff in 2021, but I wouldn’t say I’ve got anything like canonical answers on what their reservations are about 1. measuring outcomes in terms of SWB - Alex Berger’s recent technical update didn’t comment on this—and 2. doing more research or grantmaking into the things that, from the SWB perspective, seem overlooked.
This is an interesting conversation. It’s veering off into a separate topic. I wish there was a way to “rebase” these spin-off discussions into a different place. For better organisation.