The Germany argument works better the other way round: there were plenty of non-communist alternatives to Hitler (and the communists weren’t capable of winning at the ballot box), but a lot of Germans who didn’t share his race obsession thought he had some really good ideas worth listening to, and then many moderate rivals eventually concluded they were better off working with him.
I don’t think it’s “punishing” people not to give them keynote addresses and citations as allies. I doubt Leif Wenar is getting invitations to speak at EA events any time soon, not because he’s an intolerable human being but simply because his core messaging is completely incompatible with what EA is trying to do...
The Germany argument works better the other way round: there were plenty of non-communist alternatives to Hitler (and the communists weren’t capable of winning at the ballot box), but a lot of Germans who didn’t share his race obsession thought he had some really good ideas worth listening to, and then many moderate rivals eventually concluded they were better off working with him.
I don’t think it’s “punishing” people not to give them keynote addresses and citations as allies. I doubt Leif Wenar is getting invitations to speak at EA events any time soon, not because he’s an intolerable human being but simply because his core messaging is completely incompatible with what EA is trying to do...