is that you feel that moral statements are not as evidently subjective as say, ‘Vanilla ice-cream is the best flavor’ but not as objective as, say ‘An electron has a negative charge’, as living in some space of in-betweeness with respect to those two extremes
I think that’s roughly right. I think that they are unlikely to be more objective than “blue is a more natural concept than grue”, but that there’s a good chance that they’re about the same as that (and my gut take is that that’s pretty far towards the electron end of the spectrum; but perhaps I’m confused).
I’d say again, an electron doesn’t care for what a human or any other creature thinks about its electric charge.
Yeah, but I think that e.g. facts about economics are in some sense contingent on the thinking of people, but are not contingent on what particular people think, and I think that something similar could be true of morality.
I, on the contrary, don’t feel like there could be ‘moral experts’
The cleanest example I might give is that if I had a message from my near-future self saying “hey I’ve thought really hard about this issue and I really think X is right, sorry I don’t have time to unpack all of that”, I’d be pretty inclined to defer. I wonder if you feel differently?
I don’t think that moral philosophers in our society are necessarily hitting the bar I would like for “moral expert”. I also don’t think that people who are genuinely experts in morality would necessarily act according to moral values. (I’m not sure that these points are very important.)
I think that’s roughly right. I think that they are unlikely to be more objective than “blue is a more natural concept than grue”, but that there’s a good chance that they’re about the same as that (and my gut take is that that’s pretty far towards the electron end of the spectrum; but perhaps I’m confused).
Yeah, but I think that e.g. facts about economics are in some sense contingent on the thinking of people, but are not contingent on what particular people think, and I think that something similar could be true of morality.
The cleanest example I might give is that if I had a message from my near-future self saying “hey I’ve thought really hard about this issue and I really think X is right, sorry I don’t have time to unpack all of that”, I’d be pretty inclined to defer. I wonder if you feel differently?
I don’t think that moral philosophers in our society are necessarily hitting the bar I would like for “moral expert”. I also don’t think that people who are genuinely experts in morality would necessarily act according to moral values. (I’m not sure that these points are very important.)