How is this different from, say, the external world? Like, in both cases you’ll ultimately ground out at intuitions, but nonetheless, the beliefs seem justified.
No? We can test for things like object permanence by having person A secretly put an object in a box without telling person B what it is, and then person B checking the box later on while person A is not there and seeing what’s inside of it and seeing if their reports match.
I was unable to come up with a non-assertive, non-arbitrary-feeling grounding for moral realism when I tried very hard to do this in 2021-22.
My vote isn’t further towards anti-realism, because of:
Some uncertainty about what people might think I mean by ‘objective’ (I think I have specific, unchanging, moral reasons to do particular things)
I was a committed realist before 2021, so maybe I’ll become convinced the other way! But I guess not.
How is this different from, say, the external world? Like, in both cases you’ll ultimately ground out at intuitions, but nonetheless, the beliefs seem justified.
No? We can test for things like object permanence by having person A secretly put an object in a box without telling person B what it is, and then person B checking the box later on while person A is not there and seeing what’s inside of it and seeing if their reports match.