And even if you happen to have access to people with relevant knowledge, all the arguments against the actual grantmakers offering feedback applies more strongly to them:
its time consuming, more so because they’re reading the grant app in addition to their job rather than as part of it
giving “it makes no sense” feedback is hard, more so when personal relationships are involved and the next question is going to be “how do I make it make sense?”
people might overoptimize for feedback, which is a bigger problem when the person offering the feedback has more limited knowledge of current grant selection priorities
I get that casually discussing at networking events might eliminate the bottom 10% of ideas (if everyone pushes back on your idea that ballet should be a cause area or that building friendly AI in the form of human brain emulation is easy, you probably shouldn’t pursue it), but I’m not sure how “networking” can possibly be the most efficient way of improving actual proposals. Unless—like in industrial funding—there’s a case for third party grant writer / project manager types that actually help people turn half decent ideas into well-defined fundable projects for a share of the fund?
And even if you happen to have access to people with relevant knowledge, all the arguments against the actual grantmakers offering feedback applies more strongly to them:
its time consuming, more so because they’re reading the grant app in addition to their job rather than as part of it
giving “it makes no sense” feedback is hard, more so when personal relationships are involved and the next question is going to be “how do I make it make sense?”
people might overoptimize for feedback, which is a bigger problem when the person offering the feedback has more limited knowledge of current grant selection priorities
I get that casually discussing at networking events might eliminate the bottom 10% of ideas (if everyone pushes back on your idea that ballet should be a cause area or that building friendly AI in the form of human brain emulation is easy, you probably shouldn’t pursue it), but I’m not sure how “networking” can possibly be the most efficient way of improving actual proposals. Unless—like in industrial funding—there’s a case for third party grant writer / project manager types that actually help people turn half decent ideas into well-defined fundable projects for a share of the fund?