It actually might be more complicated than what you say here, alexherwix. If a research analyst role at the Open Philanthropy Project receives 800+ job applications, then you might reasonably think that it’s better for you to continue building a local community even if you were a great candidate for that option.
In addition, for the reasons that you mention, every possible local community builder might be constantly looking for new job options in the EA community making someone who doesn’t do that a highly promising candidate. Furthermore, being a community builder is actually a surprisingly difficult job.
Another consideration is that preparation and training for a specific job at an EA organization and gaining skills leading a local group might be quite different. It might suit you more to do tasks related to community building in a local context.
yeah, you could make the argument that your counterfactual impact in local community building might be higher than working at EA org X… I didn’t (mean to) propose anything to contradict that assessment and I agree given the right circumstances. I just meant to mention that people who could reasonably expect to work at EA org X will likely do so as it IS a more prestigious thing to do than community building at the moment and will likely continue to be in the near future. I don’t necessarily like this situation, I am just calling out how I see it.
I very much agree that community building is a worthwhile opportunity (that’s why I am engaging in it myself) and I never said it’s easy… it is just less specialized than some other things one would consider to be high-value. I think that’s what you allude to in your third paragraph.
To argue a little bit more FOR community building, I would propose it’s a very useful general skill set to have for any job. It’s a lot about project and people management which is quite useful regardless the specific field you want to get into. Thus, I would be quite happy to see a more systematic approach to and support of community building than we generally see at the moment (although that might just be biased and based on my personal experiences in Germany so far).
It actually might be more complicated than what you say here, alexherwix. If a research analyst role at the Open Philanthropy Project receives 800+ job applications, then you might reasonably think that it’s better for you to continue building a local community even if you were a great candidate for that option.
In addition, for the reasons that you mention, every possible local community builder might be constantly looking for new job options in the EA community making someone who doesn’t do that a highly promising candidate. Furthermore, being a community builder is actually a surprisingly difficult job.
Another consideration is that preparation and training for a specific job at an EA organization and gaining skills leading a local group might be quite different. It might suit you more to do tasks related to community building in a local context.
yeah, you could make the argument that your counterfactual impact in local community building might be higher than working at EA org X… I didn’t (mean to) propose anything to contradict that assessment and I agree given the right circumstances. I just meant to mention that people who could reasonably expect to work at EA org X will likely do so as it IS a more prestigious thing to do than community building at the moment and will likely continue to be in the near future. I don’t necessarily like this situation, I am just calling out how I see it.
I very much agree that community building is a worthwhile opportunity (that’s why I am engaging in it myself) and I never said it’s easy… it is just less specialized than some other things one would consider to be high-value. I think that’s what you allude to in your third paragraph.
To argue a little bit more FOR community building, I would propose it’s a very useful general skill set to have for any job. It’s a lot about project and people management which is quite useful regardless the specific field you want to get into. Thus, I would be quite happy to see a more systematic approach to and support of community building than we generally see at the moment (although that might just be biased and based on my personal experiences in Germany so far).