Mathias, I’m happy to share the full spreadsheet with you or anyone else on request—just PM me for the link. In addition, anyone can see the basic structure of the model as well as two examples of working through it in our previous piece introducing the framework we used.
Making the model public opens up the possibility of it being shared without the context offered in this article, and I’m hesitant to do that before we have an opportunity to document it much more fully. My hope is that we’ll be able to do that for the next iteration.
I’d emphasize that there’s a lot of information in the article that doesn’t rely on the model at all—e.g., the expert survey results, the details about specific institutions, etc. So I don’t think whether you trust the numbers or not is all that big of a crux.
Since the model can’t yet be shared publicly, it would be valuable, I think, to have an external person from the community with experience evaluating projects (e.g. Nuño Sempere) take a closer look at it and share their impressions.
Mathias, I’m happy to share the full spreadsheet with you or anyone else on request—just PM me for the link. In addition, anyone can see the basic structure of the model as well as two examples of working through it in ourprevious pieceintroducing the framework we used.Making the model public opens up the possibility of it being shared without the context offered in this article, and I’m hesitant to do that before we have an opportunity to document it much more fully. My hope is that we’ll be able to do that for the next iteration.EDIT: I’ve decided to just let people see it for themselves since the interest in this is stronger than I thought it would be.
I’d emphasize that there’s a lot of information in the article that doesn’t rely on the model at all—e.g., the expert survey results, the details about specific institutions, etc. So I don’t think whether you trust the numbers or not is all that big of a crux.
Since the model can’t yet be shared publicly, it would be valuable, I think, to have an external person from the community with experience evaluating projects (e.g. Nuño Sempere) take a closer look at it and share their impressions.