But such a critique also falls under the second kind of critique that you said would be a “misfire”. Perhaps you meant that it’s a misfire only if the critic is trying to argue against ideal EA, but in my experience most critics are not trying to do that, they’re arguing against the EA movement.
But such a critique also falls under the second kind of critique that you said would be a “misfire”. Perhaps you meant that it’s a misfire only if the critic is trying to argue against ideal EA, but in my experience most critics are not trying to do that, they’re arguing against the EA movement.