Agreement karma indicates agreement, separate from overall quality.
FWIW, I donāt actually know what you mean/ābelieve here and whether itās different to what the post already said, because:
The post said āfraction of longtermist effortā but youāre saying āshare of highly-engaged EAsā. Maybe youāre thinking the increased share should mostly come from highly engaged EAs who arenāt currently focused on longtermist efforts? That could then be consistent with the post.
You said āfeels reasonableā, which doesnāt make it clear whether you think this actually should happen, it probably should happen, itās 10% likely it should happen, it shouldnāt happen but it wouldnāt be unreasonable for it to happen, etc.
I do mean EAs with a longtermist focus. While writing about highly-engaged EAs, I had Benjamin Toddās EAG talk in mind, in which he pointed out that only around 4% of highly-engaged EAs are working in bio.
And thanks for pointing out I should be more precise. To qualify my statement, Iām 75% confident that this should happen.
8 votes
Overall karma indicates overall quality.
Total points: 0
Agreement karma indicates agreement, separate from overall quality.
FWIW, I donāt actually know what you mean/ābelieve here and whether itās different to what the post already said, because:
The post said āfraction of longtermist effortā but youāre saying āshare of highly-engaged EAsā. Maybe youāre thinking the increased share should mostly come from highly engaged EAs who arenāt currently focused on longtermist efforts? That could then be consistent with the post.
You said āfeels reasonableā, which doesnāt make it clear whether you think this actually should happen, it probably should happen, itās 10% likely it should happen, it shouldnāt happen but it wouldnāt be unreasonable for it to happen, etc.
4 votes
Overall karma indicates overall quality.
Total points: 0
Agreement karma indicates agreement, separate from overall quality.
I do mean EAs with a longtermist focus. While writing about highly-engaged EAs, I had Benjamin Toddās EAG talk in mind, in which he pointed out that only around 4% of highly-engaged EAs are working in bio.
And thanks for pointing out I should be more precise. To qualify my statement, Iām 75% confident that this should happen.