This seems like a reasonable mistake for younger EAs to make, and I’ve seen similar mindsets frequently—but in the community, I am very happy to see that many other members are providing a voice of encouragement, but also signficantly more moderation.
But as I said in another comment, and expanded on in a reply, I’m much more concerned than you seem to be about people committing to something even more mild for their entire careers—especially if doing so as college students. Many people don’t find work in the area they hope to. Even among those that do find jobs in EA orgs and similar, which is a small proportion of those who want to, some don’t enjoy the things they would view as most impactful, and find they are unhappy and/or ineffective; having made a commitment to do whatever is most impactful seems unlikely to work well for a large fraction of those who would make such a pledge.
This seems like a reasonable mistake for younger EAs to make, and I’ve seen similar mindsets frequently—but in the community, I am very happy to see that many other members are providing a voice of encouragement, but also signficantly more moderation.
But as I said in another comment, and expanded on in a reply, I’m much more concerned than you seem to be about people committing to something even more mild for their entire careers—especially if doing so as college students. Many people don’t find work in the area they hope to. Even among those that do find jobs in EA orgs and similar, which is a small proportion of those who want to, some don’t enjoy the things they would view as most impactful, and find they are unhappy and/or ineffective; having made a commitment to do whatever is most impactful seems unlikely to work well for a large fraction of those who would make such a pledge.