I actually think there’s an appropriate sense in which it is the strongest argument—not in that it’s the most robust, but in that it has the strongest implications. I think this is why it gets brought up (and that it’s appropriate to do so).
Agreed—despite being counterintuitive, it’s not obviously a flawed argument.
I actually think there’s an appropriate sense in which it is the strongest argument—not in that it’s the most robust, but in that it has the strongest implications. I think this is why it gets brought up (and that it’s appropriate to do so).
Agreed—despite being counterintuitive, it’s not obviously a flawed argument.