yep I agree, it’s not that I actually want to split by antirealists vs not, rather the disagreement in that debate reminded me once again the plurality of different fundamental opinions on the forum. It’s the first order moral views that I think are natural delineators because I think there is a lot of arguing past each other on the forum when the real cruxes are far downstream (what is your utility function, moral weights of different species, etc)
Meta-ethical views aren’t a great way to define practical communities because they needn’t affect your first-order moral views.
Ditto ontology most of the time.
yep I agree, it’s not that I actually want to split by antirealists vs not, rather the disagreement in that debate reminded me once again the plurality of different fundamental opinions on the forum. It’s the first order moral views that I think are natural delineators because I think there is a lot of arguing past each other on the forum when the real cruxes are far downstream (what is your utility function, moral weights of different species, etc)