Cool, that’s what I expected; I was just surprised by your focus in the above comment on intervening after something had already been written and on the intervention being don’t publish rather than edit.
Why’d you strong-downvote?
That´s a good point—I expect most of these discussions to lead to edits rather than publications.
I downvoted because 1) I want to discourage more conversation on the topic and 2) I think its bad policy to ask organizations if they have any projects they decided to keep secret (because if its true they might have to lie about it)
In hindsight I think I am overthinking this, and I retracted my downvotes on this thread of comments.
Cool, that’s what I expected; I was just surprised by your focus in the above comment on intervening after something had already been written and on the intervention being don’t publish rather than edit.
Why’d you strong-downvote?
That´s a good point—I expect most of these discussions to lead to edits rather than publications.
I downvoted because 1) I want to discourage more conversation on the topic and 2) I think its bad policy to ask organizations if they have any projects they decided to keep secret (because if its true they might have to lie about it)
In hindsight I think I am overthinking this, and I retracted my downvotes on this thread of comments.