Ok, that makes sense, then. In that case, I’ll continue clinging to my strange wager as I await your next post :)
Do you think it’s fair to say that this is somewhat reminiscent of the argument you countered elsewhere in the series, that (belief in) normative anti-realism would be self-defeating? Perhaps there as well, your counterargument was valid in that there’s some question-begging going on when comparing between frameworks like that, but anti-realism could still be self-defeating in practice, for people with particular intuitions?
In that case, I’ll continue clinging to my strange wager as I await your next post :)
Haha. The intuition probably won’t get any weaker, but my next post will spell out the costs it would have to endorse this intuition as your value, as opposed to treating it as a misguiding intuition. Perhaps by reflecting on the costs and the practical inconveniences it could bring about to treat this intuition as one’s terminal value, we might come to rethink it.
Ok, that makes sense, then. In that case, I’ll continue clinging to my strange wager as I await your next post :)
Do you think it’s fair to say that this is somewhat reminiscent of the argument you countered elsewhere in the series, that (belief in) normative anti-realism would be self-defeating? Perhaps there as well, your counterargument was valid in that there’s some question-begging going on when comparing between frameworks like that, but anti-realism could still be self-defeating in practice, for people with particular intuitions?
Yes, that’s the same intuition. :)
Haha. The intuition probably won’t get any weaker, but my next post will spell out the costs it would have to endorse this intuition as your value, as opposed to treating it as a misguiding intuition. Perhaps by reflecting on the costs and the practical inconveniences it could bring about to treat this intuition as one’s terminal value, we might come to rethink it.